Slu issue

General notation questions, including advanced notation, formatting, etc., go here.

Moderators: Peter Thomsen, miker

Post Reply
User avatar
tdlucas
Posts: 73
Joined: Mon Apr 23, 2018 4:09 am
Finale Version: Finale 2014 v27.0
Operating System: Windows

Post by tdlucas » Sat Sep 08, 2018 9:55 pm

How do I indicate a slur on the bottom two notes?
Attachments
slur.JPG
slur.JPG (13.12 KiB) Viewed 6821 times


User avatar
zuill
Posts: 4418
Joined: Sat Dec 10, 2016 9:35 pm
Finale Version: Finale 2011-v26.3.1
Operating System: Windows

Post by zuill » Sat Sep 08, 2018 9:58 pm

Do you want 2 slurs, one up and one down? If so, when you enter the first, flip it (ctrl-F in Windows). Then re-enter the slur and the second one will be in the default position.

Zuill
Windows 10, Finale 2011-v26.3.1
"When all is said and done, more is said than done."

User avatar
Peter Thomsen
Posts: 6601
Joined: Fri Jul 25, 2003 6:47 pm
Finale Version: Finale v27.4
Operating System: Mac

Post by Peter Thomsen » Sat Sep 08, 2018 10:03 pm

In this example the two noteheads share a stem.

The less black you have on the page (without losing any information), the better.
IMO it is redundant to show 2 slurs.
This is spoon-feeding the user to the extreme.
Do not insult people's intelligence.
Unless it is difficult to understand the slurring, show only 1 in all versions.

Can you tell us which "many" publishers do this practice?
I do not recall any publishers who use such a style.
Mac OS X 12.6.9 (Monterey), Finale user since 1996

User avatar
zuill
Posts: 4418
Joined: Sat Dec 10, 2016 9:35 pm
Finale Version: Finale 2011-v26.3.1
Operating System: Windows

Post by zuill » Sat Sep 08, 2018 11:43 pm

Sometimes, in choral music, even if the notes share a stem, the voices each have their own slur.

Zuill
Windows 10, Finale 2011-v26.3.1
"When all is said and done, more is said than done."

User avatar
N Grossingink
Posts: 1786
Joined: Mon Dec 19, 2016 2:50 pm
Finale Version: 27.3
Operating System: Mac

Post by N Grossingink » Sat Sep 08, 2018 11:51 pm

My opinion - only one slur is needed (band and orchestra scores). The double slur is an antiquated practice, from what I've seen.

N.
N. Grossingink
Educational Band, Orchestra and Jazz Ensemble a specialty
Sample: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1pFF5OeJDeLFGHMRyXrubFqZWXBubErw4/view?usp=share_link


Mac Mini 2014 2.6 Ghz, 8Gb RAM
OSX 10.15.7
Finale 2012c, 25.5, 26.3, 27.3

Nick Mazuk
Posts: 181
Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2018 12:29 am
Finale Version: Finale 26
Operating System: Mac

Post by Nick Mazuk » Sun Sep 09, 2018 12:17 am

For choral music, I wouldn't be surprised if the double slur is to show a melisma in both voices. I'm not terribly versed in choral music, but that would make sense to me.

My personal opinion is to have as little ink as possible on the page. Everything on the page is something that a player/conductor needs to parse. And that takes time. If something is clearly implied, I don't write it.
Nick

User avatar
zuill
Posts: 4418
Joined: Sat Dec 10, 2016 9:35 pm
Finale Version: Finale 2011-v26.3.1
Operating System: Windows

Post by zuill » Sun Sep 09, 2018 12:51 am

Accidentals are also handled differently in choral music when 2 parts share a staff. If the Soprano has an accidental, and then the Alto has the same accidental later in the barf, the Alto accidental is indicated. In piano scores, for example, that is not the case. I even use that philosophy when 2 players (say trumpet) share the same staff.

With slurs, I've seen it less often in instrumental music, but frequently in vocal music.

Zuill
Windows 10, Finale 2011-v26.3.1
"When all is said and done, more is said than done."

User avatar
motet
Posts: 8225
Joined: Tue Dec 06, 2016 8:33 pm
Finale Version: 2014.5,2011,2005,27
Operating System: Windows

Post by motet » Sun Sep 09, 2018 6:46 am

I think that's common practice, and Elaine Gould concurs.

She also discusses the converse situation:
Attachments
CCF_000003.png
CCF_000003.png (21.72 KiB) Viewed 6737 times

User avatar
tdlucas
Posts: 73
Joined: Mon Apr 23, 2018 4:09 am
Finale Version: Finale 2014 v27.0
Operating System: Windows

Post by tdlucas » Sun Sep 09, 2018 9:59 pm

N Grossingink wrote:My opinion - only one slur is needed (band and orchestra scores). The double slur is an antiquated practice, from what I've seen.

N.
Would you also say that this extra slur is an antiquated practice? (I would)
Attachments
extra slur.JPG
extra slur.JPG (17.95 KiB) Viewed 6701 times

Nick Mazuk
Posts: 181
Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2018 12:29 am
Finale Version: Finale 26
Operating System: Mac

Post by Nick Mazuk » Sun Sep 09, 2018 10:36 pm

I would not use either of those slurs. Definitely using two slurs in that situation is more information that what you would need. I would slur from the first note to the end of the tied note.
Attachments
Screen Shot 2018-09-09 at 3.36.02 PM.png
Screen Shot 2018-09-09 at 3.36.02 PM.png (13.38 KiB) Viewed 6691 times
Nick

User avatar
OCTO
Posts: 293
Joined: Mon Dec 19, 2016 8:43 am
Finale Version: 25
Operating System: Mac

Post by OCTO » Mon Sep 10, 2018 7:53 am

Nick Mazuk wrote:I would not use either of those slurs. Definitely using two slurs in that situation is more information that what you would need. I would slur from the first note to the end of the tied note.
That is the correct way, indeed.
www.notat.io - A Forum devoted to the Practice of Music Notation

Vaughan
Posts: 267
Joined: Wed May 12, 2010 2:50 pm
Finale Version: Finale 25
Operating System: Mac

Post by Vaughan » Mon Sep 10, 2018 9:50 am

There are different thoughts about this last practice. I've always slurred to the last tied note as well, but sometimes, especially with a long series of tied notes, this leads to a lot of clutter. In such cases, it would be better to slur to the first of the tied notes.
Vaughan

Finale 3.2 - 26, Sibelius 4 - 7, Dorico 2.2
Tobias Giesen's plugins, full version, Robert Patterson plugins, Jari's plugins
MacOS 10.14.2
MacPro (2016) 16 GB, MacBookPro (2018) 16 GB

Amsterdam

User avatar
OCTO
Posts: 293
Joined: Mon Dec 19, 2016 8:43 am
Finale Version: 25
Operating System: Mac

Post by OCTO » Mon Sep 10, 2018 11:14 am

Vaughan wrote:There are different thoughts about this last practice. I've always slurred to the last tied note as well, but sometimes, especially with a long series of tied notes, this leads to a lot of clutter. In such cases, it would be better to slur to the first of the tied notes.
Yes, that is exception of the rule, yet there is The rule.
This exception is often seen in long phrases usually in the piano literature, particularly Chopin or the same period. Sometimes is even tie used as a connection between two very long slurs.
www.notat.io - A Forum devoted to the Practice of Music Notation

User avatar
Peter Thomsen
Posts: 6601
Joined: Fri Jul 25, 2003 6:47 pm
Finale Version: Finale v27.4
Operating System: Mac

Post by Peter Thomsen » Mon Sep 10, 2018 11:18 am

Vaughan wrote:… I've always slurred to the last tied note as well, but sometimes, especially with a long series of tied notes, this leads to a lot of clutter. In such cases, it would be better to slur to the first of the tied notes.
The idea of slurring to the last tied note is that the performer can clearly distinguish between slurs and ties.
But that idea can indeed lead to clutter, especially if the slur spans across a very long tone notated as many tied notes.

Instead of slurring to the first of the tied notes you can also slur to the next tied note (as shown in the graphic tdlucas posted).
The slur gets longer, but only a little - and the slur/tie notation is clear.
Mac OS X 12.6.9 (Monterey), Finale user since 1996

Vaughan
Posts: 267
Joined: Wed May 12, 2010 2:50 pm
Finale Version: Finale 25
Operating System: Mac

Post by Vaughan » Mon Sep 10, 2018 11:24 am

True, but tieing to the second note seems a bit arbitrary. In tdlucas' example, the interval is large enough so as to make it quite clear that the first curve is indeed a slur and not a tie. Having clearly different settings for tie and slur placement helps, as well.
Vaughan

Finale 3.2 - 26, Sibelius 4 - 7, Dorico 2.2
Tobias Giesen's plugins, full version, Robert Patterson plugins, Jari's plugins
MacOS 10.14.2
MacPro (2016) 16 GB, MacBookPro (2018) 16 GB

Amsterdam

User avatar
John Ruggero
Posts: 827
Joined: Tue Dec 06, 2016 11:41 am
Finale Version: Finale 25.5
Operating System: Mac

Post by John Ruggero » Mon Sep 10, 2018 11:32 pm

To illustrate the point by several of the posters: one may avoid notational clutter by slurring from the last note or to the first note of a series of tied notes. This practice also allowed earlier composers to express subtle ideas, as in the following examples from the first movement of Beethoven's Piano Sonata op. 10 no 1. The slurs highlight the resolution of the suspensions from the exact point of dissonance rather than a point of consonance, which can make a big difference in the interpretation:
Beethoven op 10 no 1 examples.png
Beethoven op 10 no 1 examples.png (143.39 KiB) Viewed 6574 times
19th editors like those of the Breitkopt Complete Works made some of these slurs conform to their "house style" by including both tied notes in the slur. This does violence to the music in that the moment of tension is in effect hidden from view:
Beethoven op 10 no 1 B&H.jpeg
Beethoven op 10 no 1 B&H.jpeg (53.13 KiB) Viewed 6574 times
Then 20th century editors came along and created complete havoc by joining the slurs into a great hodgepodge, which conceals the working out of a three note motive:
Beethoven op 10 no 1 Casella.jpeg
Beethoven op 10 no 1 Casella.jpeg (81.58 KiB) Viewed 6574 times
Paradoxically, the very simplicity of Beethoven's notational approach allowed him to express complex ideas.

Back to the original example from the OP (and as mentioned by several posters) if the example is intended for a single instrument, it is universally understood that slur would apply to both voices, and an additional slur for the lower voice would only be necessary to clarify a special effect.
2020 M1 Mac mini (OS 12.6) Finale 25.5, Dorico, Affinity Publisher, SmartScore 64 Pro, JW Plug-ins, TG Tools, Keyboard Maestro
www.cantilenapress.com

"The better the composer, the better the notation."

User avatar
motet
Posts: 8225
Joined: Tue Dec 06, 2016 8:33 pm
Finale Version: 2014.5,2011,2005,27
Operating System: Windows

Post by motet » Tue Sep 11, 2018 1:01 am

It should be all about clarity and cleanness rather than arbitrarily applying a rule (really, more a matter of style than a notational rule).

User avatar
David Ward
Posts: 814
Joined: Thu Dec 01, 2016 4:48 pm
Finale Version: F 25.5 & 26.3
Operating System: Mac

Post by David Ward » Tue Sep 11, 2018 6:45 am

motet wrote:It should be all about clarity and cleanness rather than arbitrarily applying a rule… …
As someone (I think Group Captain Sir Douglas Bader, WW2 fighter pilot) said: “Rules are for the obedience of fools and the guidance of the wise.”
Finale 25.5 & 26.3
Mac 10.13.6 & 10.14.6

User avatar
Peter Thomsen
Posts: 6601
Joined: Fri Jul 25, 2003 6:47 pm
Finale Version: Finale v27.4
Operating System: Mac

Post by Peter Thomsen » Tue Sep 11, 2018 9:52 am

David Ward wrote:… (I think Group Captain Sir Douglas Bader, WW2 fighter pilot) …
Or perhaps Harry Day.
Mac OS X 12.6.9 (Monterey), Finale user since 1996

Post Reply