Trill assigned by neighoring instrument
Posted: Wed Jul 20, 2022 3:52 pm
I have read of the many problems of Human Playback and Trills, starting late, Ending early etc. Here is a trill error I have that I cannot seem to clear.
A trill in Bb Clarinet 1 that activates a trill in the bassoon part during HP (Standard and Marching Band). I am using Finale 26 3.1 520 build. I have made sure that the trill is marked to the correct part, and repeated this exercise several times. This effect only occurs in 3-4 measures, with similar note relationships both before and after these measures. Using Edit Clear Selected Items, no combination of clearings seems to remove the trill effect. I have deleted the bassoon measures and re-written them only to have the trill return like an unwanted guest. The Oboe trill has no effect on the bassoon. The only time I removed the trill effect was to delete the trill mark from Bb Clarinet 1. Once adding the trill back to the Clarinet, it also affects the bassoon. Again, using the arrow indicators when applying the trill, this should belong only to the Clarinet. I even moved the Bassoon staff further away from the Clarinet to attempt to isolate it. Finally, I deleted the Clarinet trill, bassoon sounded as written, added the Clarinet trill back to the part but I placed the trill markings within the Clarinet staff, and magically, no bassoon trill. When moving the Clarinet trill back up to its rightful place, over the whole note, the bassoon trill returned suggesting the placement of the trill mark was affecting the bassoon part. It is possible that my first attempt to add trills may have given the bassoon a trill, but that mistake has been corrected long ago, yet the bassoon still trills.
Any suggestions on how to remove the trill from the bassoon and yet retain it for the Clarinet? Or why only these few measures seem to behave this way?
A trill in Bb Clarinet 1 that activates a trill in the bassoon part during HP (Standard and Marching Band). I am using Finale 26 3.1 520 build. I have made sure that the trill is marked to the correct part, and repeated this exercise several times. This effect only occurs in 3-4 measures, with similar note relationships both before and after these measures. Using Edit Clear Selected Items, no combination of clearings seems to remove the trill effect. I have deleted the bassoon measures and re-written them only to have the trill return like an unwanted guest. The Oboe trill has no effect on the bassoon. The only time I removed the trill effect was to delete the trill mark from Bb Clarinet 1. Once adding the trill back to the Clarinet, it also affects the bassoon. Again, using the arrow indicators when applying the trill, this should belong only to the Clarinet. I even moved the Bassoon staff further away from the Clarinet to attempt to isolate it. Finally, I deleted the Clarinet trill, bassoon sounded as written, added the Clarinet trill back to the part but I placed the trill markings within the Clarinet staff, and magically, no bassoon trill. When moving the Clarinet trill back up to its rightful place, over the whole note, the bassoon trill returned suggesting the placement of the trill mark was affecting the bassoon part. It is possible that my first attempt to add trills may have given the bassoon a trill, but that mistake has been corrected long ago, yet the bassoon still trills.
Any suggestions on how to remove the trill from the bassoon and yet retain it for the Clarinet? Or why only these few measures seem to behave this way?